AI: Opportunity or Threat for Wealth Management

The AI debate in investment management should not centre on the fears outlined by the Investment Association. Instead, it should focus on how firms can use AI to drive down costs and deliver better value and better service to clients.

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is revolutionary and reshaping industries worldwide, and investment management is no exception. While concerns about AI adoption, such as those raised by the Investment Association (IA) see link, warrant attention, the tangible benefits, particularly for small to medium size firms such as ours, far outweigh the risks.

Our commitment to offering clients more modern, low-cost, accessible, 100% transparent, and client-focused investment solutions drives our AI strategy. A strategy designed to enhance operational efficiency, pass on cost savings and improving the service SCM Direct delivers to clients.

A Conflicted Investment Association
Before delving into AI’s benefits, we pose the fundamental question: Why does the Investment Association exist? Their self-proclaimed mission is to “make investment better,” yet their members often represent an industry riddled with high fees, poor services and significant inefficiencies.

At SCM Direct, we pride ourselves on our flat, efficient organisational structure, which enables us to charge lower fees to clients. We question the relevance of organisations like the Investment Association, which frequently perpetuate the status quo and represent the dinosaurs of the industry, who lack the mindset or vision to embrace meaningful change. Utilising AI, firms can reduce costs, ensuring more of client’s returns from THEIR money go back into their pockets, and significantly improve service quality.

AI Delivers Efficiency and Cost Savings
In the IA’s recent discussion on AI they appear preoccupied with risks such as bias, over-reliance on technology, and implementation challenges. While these concerns are valid, they should not obscure the clear advantages of AI.

At SCM Direct, we have been deploying AI to reduce costs and improve decision-making capabilities drastically. For example, one of our in-house tools allows us to analyse the characteristics of over 500 Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) within minutes, leveraging AI’s programming and analytical capabilities to automate vast and complex data processes. This enables our investment team to assess underlying fundamentals such as valuation, liquidity, and exposures in our ETFs more comprehensively than traditional methods. Traditional methods that struggle to analyse even a fraction of that number in the same timeframe. This leap in efficiency is not merely about speed; it’s about doing more with less.

By automating our more labour-intensive processes, such as data analysis and compliance checks, we can not only pass operational savings directly to our clients, we can also easily spot trends and any anomalies. Our commitment to cost-efficiency is central to our business model and means we try to keep up to date on all tools – AI can enhance our operation and offering. Unlike the broader, older industry, which often burdens clients with unnecessary fees, long-timelines and burdensome paperwork, SCM Direct’s approach ensures that clients experience less fees, less admin, higher levels of customer service and transparency of holdings within their portfolios.

With AI, Increased Compliance Does Not Mean Increased Costs
The UK’s regulatory landscape, including the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) rules and guidance, necessitates that investment firms adapt quickly and accurately. Whatever your views on this, compliance is here to stay and more than likely to increase. We have found that the strategic use of AI significantly enhances our regulatory compliance without increasing operational costs. At SCM Direct, AI allows us to rapidly review contracts, marketing materials, client documentation, adverts and communications to ensure compliance with financial regulations and wider UK law. This reduces the risk of human error and substantially cuts down the time and resources needed for manual reviews.

Our AI tools ensure that materials undergo multiple levels of review – by the AI, human compliance officers, and external (human) experts – before reaching clients or prospective clients. This approach aligns with best practices, reduces costs, and allows us to avoid the bloated compliance teams typical of larger firms.

Overcoming Barriers Through a Focused and Efficient Approach
The IA’s report also mentions internal barriers to AI adoption, such as cultural resistance and skill gaps. At SCM Direct, we view these challenges differently. Our lean, technology-driven structure is an advantage, not a hindrance. We focus on upskilling our team to work with AI rather than being overwhelmed by it. By automating routine/more mundane tasks, AI frees up our employees and allows them to focus on value-added activities, such as personalised client service, strategic decision-making and creativity.

For example, our AI-powered tools have enabled us to develop a program that can scan hundreds of client reports in minutes to generate detailed analyses of fees and charges. A process that used to take weeks using traditional methods. This is not just about meeting regulatory demands; it’s about embracing them in a way that minimises costs and maximises customer value.

Questioning and Testing AI’s Output
Whilst SCM Direct embraces AI, we do not embrace these tools blindly. Even though it can handle large datasets, routine tasks, programming, and converting formats, we have human oversight that is constantly questioning and testing all outputs.

Our experience is that it is unwise to assume that the first solution/output is either the best or even 100% correct, as AI can make numerous mistakes and false assumptions. So AI is not a total replacer, it is an enhancer that still requires human oversight, experience, and intellect to guide it down the right path and challenge its often flawed output. For SCM Direct, AI is a powerful tool in our armoury to keep us lean, efficient and sharp, but we still need human judgement in interpreting its results.

AI does pose risks, such as potential bias or misuse, but these are manageable. The UK government’s AI framework emphasises safety, security, and transparency – principles we integral to our company. Our processes are rigorously tested to ensure accuracy, and we continually monitor for any deviations. We use AI to enhance our services, not to replace the need for careful oversight.

The Case for Low-Cost, Client-Centric AI Adoption
We fully support the UK’s pro-innovation regulatory environment and the supporting of firms in integrating AI responsibly, but the real issue is how firms use this flexibility.

At SCM Direct, we believe that AI should serve a singular purpose: to improve client outcomes by enhancing efficiency, reducing costs, and improving service quality. Not as AI advisers or investment managers.

It may be that the IA’s broader membership is worried that too many of them will be replaced by AI or they are simply making too much money from their outdated models, clinging to legacy practices that inflate costs. Change is here now, and with AI the pace of change is accelerating, so senior managements need to get over their AI phobias, put their customers first and enhance consumer value.

Conclusion: AI is a Competitive Advantage, not a Compliance Burden
The AI debate in investment management should not centre on the fears outlined by the Investment Association. Instead, it should focus on how firms can use AI to drive down costs and deliver better value and better service to clients.

SCM Direct’s experience shows that AI, when used intelligently and efficiently, allows us to onboard regulatory requirements and changes, embrace industry trends, and more demanding customers, while maintaining a low-cost structure. This benefits our clients, investors, staff, and partners.

In a sector where high fees, poor service, average performance and inefficiency are all too common, SCM Direct is committed to setting and maintaining higher standards. Our low-cost, AI-driven approach empowers us to pass operational savings directly to our clients, delivering on our promise of cost-efficient, high-quality investment management.

Share